Skip to main content

Prefinished vs. Jobsite finished floors


Finishes for hardwood flooring have improved dramatically over the last several years, however one question still remains. Is a factory finish better than a site-finished floor, or vice versa? In this article I will talk about both types of finishes and then you can decide for yourself, which is better.

The main benefit to having a prefinished floor is that the finish is done under a controlled environment at the factory, thus ensuring a smooth uniform finish. Factory finished floors are usually coated using a water-based polyurethane with aluminum oxide particles suspended in the finish. Aluminum oxide when added to the finish makes the finish harder and more resistant to wear. Aluminum oxide may provide some additional abrasion resistance, however I do not believe it is any more scratch resistant than a site finished floor. The downside to aluminum oxide flooring is that they can be very difficult to refinish successfully. Strict procedures must be followed in order to refinish these types of floors.

Hardwood flooring that is finished on-site has its benefits too. Site finished floors have a tabletop appearance and are completely sealed with a polyurethane finish. Prefinished floors typically have a micro-bevel and are not completely sealed once installed. Also, if you choose to have a job-site finished floor, you can choose the gloss level before installation. Most prefinished floors generally have a semi-gloss coating, however some floors are available in a high gloss and matte finish. If you are looking for a low-matte prefinished hardwood floor, you may find it more difficult to find exactly what you are looking for. One of the most durable hardwood floor finishes that can be found today is called Traffic. This product is a water-based polyurethane that is second to none in the industry and is applied on-site by a sand and finish contractor. Traffic is a commercially rated finish made by Bona Kemi and is available in a satin and semi-gloss water-based urethane.

The only real way to tell which type of finish is better, is to look at the Taber abrasion test for both types of finishes. The Taber abrasion test is the main method used for testing the durability of hardwood floor finishes. Traffic by Bona Kemi has some of the highest Taber test results in the industry. For more information about these methods of testing visit: www.taberindusries.com Before you decide which type of finished floor you want, I recommend taking a look at a new site finished floor and one that is prefinished from the factory. I believe you will find that a site-finished floor is a nicer looking than its prefinished counterpart, however this is just my opinion.
Thanks,
The Floor Man

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Solid Vs. Engineered Hardwood. Which is better?

In this article I will cover the difference between engineered and solid wood flooring. I often get asked; is engineered hardwood actually real wood? The answer to that question is: Yes! There are some who think that engineered wood is inferior to its solid counterpart. Solid wood has its benefits, however it is not necessarily better than engineered. Actually, the opposite just may be true. Engineered hardwood has a cross-plywood construction, with a solid wood veneer laminated to the top. Solid hardwood is just that, solid. Both styles range in thickness from 5/16 to 3/4 inch. Both types of floors come prefinished or unfinished and come in a variety of widths and styles. There are several benefits to engineered hardwood. Here are just a few. Engineered hardwood is more dimensionally stable than solid wood flooring. Engineered floors can be glued down directly to concrete, floated or stapled. They can be installed above, on, or below grade. Engineered floors are less prone to cupping...
34 comments
Read more

Urethane vs. Acrylic adhesives

If you are about to install engineered hardwood using the glue down method, I recommend that you read this article. One of the most important factors when installing engineered hardwood is the adhesive. Using the proper adhesive is critical to a successful installation. In this article I will briefly cover the differences between Acrylic and Urethane based adhesives. Let me start with acrylic adhesives. Acrylic adhesives are resin based and contain a certain percentage of water in them. The main problem with resin based adhesives, is the lack of tensile strength. In order for Acrylic adhesives to perform at their optimal level, the sub-floor needs to be well prepared and extremely flat. If the sub-floor is not level and flat and you choose to use an acrylic adhesive, I guarantee you will have hollow spots once the job is complete. Hollow spots are areas in which the wood floor is not adhered properly to the substrate. This problem is common and can be recognized by a popping or hollow ...
3 comments
Read more

Hardwax Oil vs. Urethane Finishes

In the early to mid 1980's,  a new type of urethane fini sh entered the market; water-base urethane was the new craze. With the entrance of water-base into the market-place, contractors quickly began to realize its value. The new water-base finishes added extra durability, dried much faster than its counterpart, and reduced the amount of labor hours. Prior to urethane finishes, hardwood floors were often sealed with multiple layers of shellac (lacquer was also popular); contractors would apply a coat of hot wax, which acted as a protective barrier. Finally, contractors would then polish the floor; finishing it up. Now, almost after a half of a century, the new craze is here; "Hardwax Oil".  Made from waxes and oils, such as carnauba and parrafin wax, and natural oils, such as sunflower and linseed. Hardwax Oil is quickly gaining favor in the hardwood finish industry. So, the question is, which is better. Urethane or Hardwax Oil?...
10 comments
Read more